Can put your head through a piece of paper? Even with a full-size piece of printer paper, this can seem impossible. Doing it with just a strip a paper seems doubly so.
Challenging other people to stick their head through a piece of paper makes for a fun gag, because its achievement initially seems hopeless, and then becomes delightfully revelatory once you know the secret. Which goes like this:
Step 1: Cut a piece of paper into fourths.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/026c6/026c6336ac86bf71a64eafada973bfd13f74cea2" alt=""
The challenge is more impressive when you do it with smaller pieces of paper. It can be done with paper as small as 2 X 5.5 inches.
Step 2: Fold the paper in half lengthwise.
Step 3: Make about 12 cuts into the folded side of the paper.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bbca6/bbca67d3199f68fed972b8b631888fda21fc9af2" alt=""
Do not cut all the way through.
Step 4: Make cuts in the open side, cutting between the cuts you just made on the folded side.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e5cdd/e5cdd8e87ca65615a0d74fc9eed92fc84be6c59a" alt=""
Do not cut all the way through.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ffd54/ffd5423e83984f2caa7c5b728bade99171f87929" alt=""
This is what it should look like.
Step 5: Cut across the fold, beginning from inside the first cut and ending at the last.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1b8f2/1b8f20b2796e74678736c8b18ce759201fe4d1c0" alt=""
Do not cut through the edges of the paper.